While Oregon moves to fund assisting suicide as part of its health
care rationing plan for the poor and the first news accounts of people getting
lethal prescriptions are being published, other states are rejecting efforts
to legalize the practice and moving to enact protective legislation.
In Maine, an Oregon-style bill to legalize assisting suicide was defeated
by the House 99 to 42 on February 11 and by the Senate 25 to 5 on February
12. In New Hampshire, a similar bill was effectively defeated for the session
when the House Judiciary and Family Law Committee voted 13 to 7 to refer
it for interim study.
In Michigan, Jack Kevorkian continues his involvement in assisted suicides.
According to Reuters, Kevorkian has now admitted to "helping"
80-100
people die, including those with disabilities and those with mental illnesses
(see story on page 4). However, in December the Michigan Senate voted 28
to 7 for a law imposing permanent criminal penalties on assisted suicide
and House action on the bill is expected soon. If it passes, Governor John
Engler is expected to sign the measure.
In Kansas legislation to provide for civil remedies to prevent assisted
suicide was approved by the House 111 to 13 on February 17. Similar legislation
was passed on March 11 in the Oklahoma Senate by a vote of 47-0 and in the
House, in addition to passage in the Virginia House, 77 to 20, on February
17, and by the Virginia Senate, 34-6, on March 11.
Meanwhile, in Oregon the Health Services Commission February 26 voted 10-1
to include physician-assisted suicide on the list of items for which the
state's Medicaid program pays, as part of a category called "terminal
illness, regardless of diagnosis," which is ranked number 260 of 745
items. Under the Oregon rationing plan, budgetary considerations determine
how many of the 745 categories of medical treatment receive funding. The
relatively high ranking of the category including assisting suicide probably
guarantees that it will receive funding, while some categories of lifesaving
medical treatment ranked lower on the list will not. In some cases, therefore,
Oregon will pay for poor people to kill themselves, but not to keep themselves
alive.
According to a February 18 Portland Oregonian article, at least 10
people had formally requested lethal prescriptions, one of whom had completed
all the steps and received the drugs, although the individual had not yet
used the drugs to commit suicide. Some of those who applied died naturally
during the 15-day waiting period.
In November, federal Drug Enforcement Administrator Thomas Constantine,
in a letter to the chairmen of the Senate and House Judiciary Committees,
stated that prescribing federally controlled substances, such as narcotics
and other dangerous drugs, to assist a suicide violates federal law and
could result in suspending or revoking a doctor's registration to dispense
such federally controlled substances. Shortly thereafter, however, Attorney
General Janet Reno publicly announced that she had not been consulted by
Constantine, and that his determination would be subject to Justice Department
review and possible reversal.
Subsequently, that internal review recommended that the DEA determination
be overturned, but at press time Reno had not yet formally acted to do so,
while awaiting comments from the DEA and others on the internal review's
report. Nevertheless, Oregon doctors willing to practice euthanasia seem
to have concluded that they are no longer at risk of adverse DEA action,
and are proceeding to implement the law.
65% OPPOSE USE OF FEDERALLY CONTROLLED
DRUGS
FOR EUTHANASIA
By a margin of more than 2 to 1, Americans oppose the use of federally controlled drugs for assisted suicide and euthanasia. In a nationwide telephone poll conducted March 7-9, 1998 by Wirthlin Worldwide, 511 Americans were asked this question with the following results:
The margin of error was 4.3% with a 95% confidence interval, meaning that if every American had been asked the question, 95 out of 100 times the results would have been within 4.3% of those given by this sample.