Today's News & Views
May 9, 2006
 

Andrea Clark: Rest in Peace

Those who've read previous editions of TN&V or visited our web page are familiar with the case of Andrea Clark. You'll remember that a local Texas hospital sought to use a state "futility" law as cover not to treat Andrea Clark.

At the eleventh hour a physician was found who agreed to care for her. Andrea Clark's health was fragile following open heart surgery, but that ought never have been used to try to justify non-treatment.

Her family has sent out a statement saying that she'd died peacefully on Sunday afternoon, surrounded by two sisters, her brother, and her son, five days after the hospital withdrew its plans to halt treatment and food and water. Wesley Smith posted the announcement on his blog, www.wesleyjsmith.com

"Andrea passed away peacefully a little before 3pm today, with her family and her friends at her bedside. We love her so very much and we are going to miss her terribly. We hope that the battle that we fought for our sister will bring to light and bear witness to the horrible acts committed in the name of ethics in hospitals across the state of Texas.

"The fact that we had to fight this battle is both frightening and a sad commentary on the so-called 'ethics' now being practiced in medical facilities in this state. The battle for life is a difficult one, in the best of situations, but when a family is put through what we had to go through at such a time, it is especially agonizing.

"We wish so much that we could have spent more time at our sister's side, when she was living and fighting for her life, rather than having to visit our attorney's office, give interviews to radio and television stations to let the public know of the atrocity about to befall Andrea, and literally stand outside the hospital and beg them not to kill our sister. In attempting to deprive Andrea of the most basic of her human rights--life--St. Luke's Hospital managed to deprive her family and her of that which is most dear to us all, when we are faced with the death of a loved one: a proper goodbye.

"How, in the name of God, anyone can call putting someone to death when they are at their most helpless and begging for their lives 'ethical,' we cannot imagine."

According to this morning's Houston Chronicle, Lanore Dixon, Andrea Clark's sister, has vowed to overturn the Texas law.

"We're never going to stop working to change the law," Lanore Dixon said. "We hope that the battle we fought for our sister will bring to light and bear witness to the horrible acts committed in the name of ethics in hospitals across the state of Texas."

Todd Ackerman, reporting for the Chronicle, wrote today,

"The 1999 law, commonly known as Texas' futile-care law, is the subject of ongoing meetings in Austin aimed at reform in the 2007 Legislature. It allows a hospital to remove life support in a case deemed medically futile, as long as its ethics committee agrees with the attending physicians' recommendation and gives the patient's family 10 days of notice to find an alternative facility.

"Three high-profile Houston cases brought the little-known law to the public's attention in 2005. The lawyer who represented Clark's family is trying to find a Texas facility to accept a patient scheduled to be removed from life support at an Austin hospital later this month."

Our prayers go out to Andrea Clark's family.