The Shadowy World of Assisted
Suicide
Part One of Two
By Dave Andrusko
Editor's note. Be sure also to post this
TN&V on your social networking pages by
going to
www.nrlc.org/News_and_views/Mar09/nv031209.html
and clicking on the "Share" button.
Part Two
is a wonderfully helpful explanation of the
resources available at
www.nrlc.org.
"Mr. [Derek] Humphry said
the network's protocols were deliberately
written to avoid illegality. 'The person
does everything themselves,' he said. ''They
don the hood. They tie it around their neck.
They reach forward. They turn on the gas.'''
Quoted in yesterday's New York Times. Humphry is
chairman of the "Final Exit Network's"
advisory board. The group promotes Humphry's
suicide
manual, "Final Exit."
Two weeks ago I wrote about
"Alleged
Assisted Suicide Ring Busted." If you're
interested you can find out what my take on
the Final Exit Network at
http://www.nrlc.org/News_and_Views/Feb09/nv022709.html.
The New York Times picked up the
story thread yesterday.
The assisted suicide lobby has no more
faithful friend, no more aggressive advocate
or vociferous cheerleader than the Times.
We've long since come to expect that the
publication whose motto is "all the news
that's fit to print" would only print news
about assisted suicide that says it "honors"
patient's
wishes
and
avoids
having
it done
"underground
or covertly, with hushed tones," as Barbara
Coombs Lee, the president of pro-euthanasia
Compassion and Choices, told the Times
yesterday.
Robbie Brown's
"Arrests of Right-to-Die Officials Focus New
Attention on Assisted Suicide" is far more
balanced than the usual
legalize-this-now-or-you-are-an-uncaring-cad
malarkey we are accustomed to reading in the
Times. Having read the
1,104-word-long piece you'd know, for
example, that "Officials with the Georgia
Bureau of Investigation [GBI) say the
network,
which
says it
has
3,000
dues-paying
members
in the
United
States,
actively
takes
part in
suicides,
an act
that is
illegal
in every
state
except
Oregon
and
Washington."
And that ''The
law is clear, and they clearly violated
it,'' said John Bankhead, a spokesman for
the GBI. And that, according to the group's
literature, "members receive services
including
'counseling,
support
and even
guidance'
on
suicide,
in
exchange
for an
annual
$50
fee."
Ever more
significantly the story lets the reader know
early on, "The arrests raised questions
about
whether
the
group,
which
has
helped
some 200
people
commit
suicide
since
2004,
merely
watched
people
take the
leap
into
death,
or
pushed
them
over the
edge."
As you know from
our account and the Times story
yesterday, an investigator with the GBI
posed as a cancer patient. The Network
agreed to help him commit suicide and
actually went through a dry run.
'''Mr. [Thomas
E.] Goodwin [president of the group] got on
top of the agent and held down both of his
hands,' Bankhead told the Times,
"which
investigators
say
would
have
prevented
him from
removing
the mask
if he
had
changed
his mind
during a
real
suicide."
The
eight-month-long investigation began when
the family of a Georgia man, John Celmer,
who committed suicide in June, got
suspicious. Celmer's wife, Susan, found
one of the letters he had sent to the
Final Exit Network "as well as release forms
he had signed for the group," the Los
Angeles Times reported.
Eventually, four members were arrested,
included Goodwin, and medical director, Dr.
Lawrence D. Egbert. They were charged with
assisted suicide, tampering with evidence,
and violation of the Georgia RICO (Racketeer
Influenced and Corrupt Organizations) Act.
The group is arguing their actions were
above board.
''Assisted suicide is Jack Kevorkian putting
a needle in someone with a deadly
substance,'' Jerry Dincin (who became the
network president after the arrests) told
the Times. ''We provide information
that we think is protected under the First
Amendment.''
As for Goodman's
actions, Humphry said members (called "exit
guides") do often hold the person's hands
"but for
support,
not
restraint."
How do they die?
By asphyxiation. A hood (the "exit bag") is
placed over their heads and helium is pumped
in until the patient loses consciousness.
Death can take 10 or 20 minutes
longer.
So, how
"discriminating" was the Final Exit Network
when approached by people asking to be
assisted to die? "Of the 200
applications for death, Dr. Lawrence Egbert
approved them all," the Atlantic
Journal-Constitution reported over the
weekend.
Stephen Drake of the group
Not Dead Yet, cut to the chase. "It's like
approaching somebody who is on the ledge of
a building and giving them a shove instead
of pulling them back."
Please send your comments to
daveandrusko@gmail.com. They are
much appreciated.
Part Two: "The
Internet and NRLC"