C-SPAN Challenges Congress to
Open Health Care Talks to TV
Coverage
Part One of Two
By Dave Andrusko
Part Two discusses a
pro-abortion "wish list." Please
send your comments and
observations to
daveandrusko@gmail.com.
If you'd like, follow me on
http://twitter.com/daveha.
The headline for this edition of
TN&V is the headline that
appeared over a story carried
this morning at FOXNews.com.
C-SPAN CEO Brian Lamb sent
congressional leaders a letter
which (to quote Fox News)
"implored Congress to open up
the last leg of health care
reform negotiations to the
public, as top Democrats lay
plans to hash out the final
product among themselves." (The
full letter is reproduced at the
end of this edition.)
That Lamb would even have to ask
is, if you think about it,
stunning.
The greatest change in American
governmental structure in 40+
years will be thrashed out in
secret by Democratic leaders of
the House and Senate and
representatives for President
Barack Obama. The customary
practice of reconciling the
differences between the House
bill (which includes the
pro-life Stupak-Pitts Amendment)
and the Senate bill (which does
not) in a conference committee
is, by all reports, to be
ditched.
 |
|
Then-Sen. Barack Obama
helps Sen. Hillary
Rodham Clinton to her
seat before the start of
a Democratic
presidential primary
debate held January 31,
2008, in Los Angeles. |
Promises of transparency have
been proven yet again to be
transparently bogus. As Doug
Heye, writing on a blog found at
US News & World Report reminds
us, "Even while Reid declared in
November that transparency is
'one of the guiding principles
of health insurance reform,'
Democrats sought to work out the
final details of the bill in
secret and rush a new bill
through before the American
people know what hit them."
Why? "Poll after poll has shown
the [health care restructuring]
legislation to be wildly
unpopular with voters," Heye
wrote this morning, "and we all
saw what happened when everyday
Americans had the opportunity to
voice their opinion to their
elected officials during the
August recess--bedlam."
As for Obama's part, I think
many of our readers probably
remember his almost two-year-old
"cross my fingers, hope to die"
promise to invite C-SPAN cameras
in for gavel-to-gavel coverage.
"That's what I will do in
bringing all parties together,
not negotiating behind closed
doors, but bringing all parties
together, and broadcasting those
negotiations on C-SPAN so that
the American people can see what
the choices are," Obama said in
a debate against presidential
rival Hillary Clinton on Jan.
31, 2008.
Lamb and C-SPAN have assumed
almost legendary status for
their objective, non-partisan
coverage. Although his request
will doubtless be ignored, in so
doing the pro-abortion
congressional leadership and
pro-abortion President Obama are
sending a terrible message to
the electorate while
simultaneously offering a
reminder that power corrupts and
absolute power corrupts
absolutely.
To quote just one paragraph from
the letter dated December 30 and
released today:
"President Obama, Senate and
House leaders, many of your
rank-and-file members, and the
nation's editorial pages have
all talked about the value of
transparent discussions on
reforming the nation's health
care system," Lamb wrote.
"Now that the process moves to
the critical stage of
reconciliation between the
chambers, we respectfully
request that you allow the
public full access, through
television, to legislation that
will affect the lives of every
single American."
The letter is reproduced below.
Following that is one concluding
thought.
Dear Speaker Pelosi:
Representative Boehner:
Senator Reid:
Senator McConnell:
As your respective chambers work
to reconcile the differences
between the House and Senate
health care bills, C-SPAN
requests that you open all
important negotiations,
including any conference
committee meetings, to
electronic media coverage.
The C-SPAN networks will commit
the necessary resources to
covering all of these sessions
LIVE and in their entirety. We
will also, as we willingly do
each day, provide C-SPAN's
multi-camera coverage to any
interested member of the Capitol
Hill broadcast pool.
Since the initial introduction
of the America's Affordable
Health Care Act of 2009 in the
House and the Patient Protection
and Affordable Care Act in the
Senate C-SPAN has televised
literally hundreds of hours of
committee hearings, mark ups and
floor debate on these bills for
the public to see. And
importantly, we have archived
all of this video for future
generations to study in the
C-SPAN Video Archives.
President Obama, Senate and
House leaders, many of your
rank-and-file members, and the
nation's editorial pages have
all talked about the value of
transparent discussions on
reforming the nation's health
care system. Now that the
process moves to the critical
stage of reconciliation between
the Chambers, we respectfully
request that you allow the
public full access, through
television, to legislation that
will affect the lives of every
single American.
We hope you will give serious
consideration to this request.
We are most willing to employ
the latest digital technology to
make the cameras, lights and
microphones as unobtrusive as
possible.
Please contact me if I can
answer any questions.
Sincerely,
Brian Lamb
While it is unhealthy for our
system of government to bypass
conference on such an historic
measure, we must not forget that
whether the bill is produced by
the amendment process now
anticipated, or through a
conference committee process,
the final bill can only reach
the President's desk after an
affirmative vote of a majority
in the House and 60 senators. It
is the substantive content, not
the way the process plays out,
that matters most.
Part Two |