Justice for Haleigh Poutre
Does Not Mitigate the Tragedy
Part One of Two
"The sentencing of Jason
Strickland was handed down three years after the
case drew national attention when the state
prematurely sought to remove [Haleigh] Poutre's
life support after she fell into a coma from a
near-fatal head injury in September 2005. A few
months later, just when the state won court
approval to end her life, saying her condition
was 'hopeless,' the 11-year-old girl became
alert, breathing on her own and responding to
commands."
From "Poutre stepfather gets 12-15 years in prison," by
Patricia Wen, which appeared in the Boston
Globe.
A friend sent a link to this
story which actually ran back in December. It is
a story of almost soul-crushing brutality and
callousness saved from utter disaster because
Haleigh began to respond just in the nick of
time.
 |
|
Haleigh Poutre |
We've written several times
about Haleigh's terrible plight. When Hampden
Superior Court Judge Judd Carhart sentenced
Jason Strickland in December, it was for his
part in what Wen characterized as a "horrific
pattern of child abuse." During the
three-week-long trial Strickland asserted
innocence, saying that he accepted the
explanation of his late wife, Holi, for the many
wounds on Haleigh--that she "had a psychological
condition that caused her to hurt herself."
As Wen wrote, "That
explanation had also been accepted, over a
five-year period, by the child's pediatricians,
therapists, and state social workers, who
dismissed allegations from neighbors and
teachers that Haleigh was being abused in her
home."
Added Wen, "The jury
ultimately found that Jason Strickland may not
have dealt the near-fatal blow to Haleigh's
head, but that he was guilty of 'recklessly
permitting' the injury to occur. The panel found
him guilty of five of the six counts, including
several instances of striking Haleigh in the
summer of 2005."
In September 2005, Haleigh's
adoptive mother and stepfather, Holi and Jason
Strickland, brought the bruised and unconscious
Haleigh to the emergency room of Noble Hospital
in Westfield, Massachusetts, "saying she had
become unresponsive after suffering flu like
symptoms," the Boston Globe reported.
"Within two days, the
Department of Social Services took custody of
the couple's two other children, and a week
later the couple was criminally charged in
connection with Haleigh's traumatic brain
injuries." Haleigh was 11 at the time.
Incredibly, only six days
after the Massachusetts Department of Social
Services (DSS) took custody of Haleigh, it asked
Juvenile Court Judge James G. Collins for
permission to remove her feeding tube and
ventilator. According to the Boston Globe, on
October 5, 2005, Collins gave the agency the
go-ahead.
Fortunately, Haleigh (who,
supposedly, was "in a vegetative state," and
"had suffered a severe brain injury, and
probably would never think or feel again") began
to breath on her own and show "increased
responsiveness." This came on January 18, 2006,
less than 24 hours after the Supreme Judicial
Court had backed the lower court's death order.
"A week later, DSS
Commissioner Harry Spence witnessed her picking
up a duck and a Curious George doll on command
and tracking some of his movements with her
eyes," according to the Globe's Wen. On Jan. 26,
DSS transferred Haleigh to the Franciscan
Hospital for Children in Brighton, where she
lives and receives physical, speech, and
occupational therapy.
The irony is that the only
reason she had remained on life support was
because of Jason Strickland's appeals, "which
delayed the process long enough that Haleigh's
condition began to improve," the Globe reported.
I look forward to reading your
comments. Please send to
daveandrusko@gmail.com.
Part Two --
Autistic Babies Should Not Be Killed. Period
|