Archbishop
Chaput's Sage Advice
Part Two of Two
Editor's note.
Please send your thoughts and
comments to
daveandrusko@gmail.com.
I've long
since learned that when I am in
the presence of someone blessed
with outsized intellectual and
moral discernment, I better be
awfully careful how I summarize
what they say. I will honor that
self-admonition when talking
today about some of the
wonderfully thought-provoking
comments made by Archbishop
Charles Chaput of Denver in a
recent overseas talk.
Based on the
lengthy American experience with
fighting abortion, Archbishop
Chaput offered a five "dos" and
six "don'ts." I will take just a
moment to focus on two of the
"don'ts."
 |
|
Archbishop Charles
Chaput |
I don't know
if there was a particular reason
for making "don't let yourselves
be tricked into an inferiority
complex" #1, but it surely is of
huge importance. Archbishop
Chaput is talking here about
authentic pluralism, not the
bogus slogan that is used as a
hammer by pro-abortionists to
pulverize pro-lifers for having
the audacity to take part in the
public square.
"In America
the word 'pluralism' is often
conjured up like a kind of
voodoo shield to get religious
people to stop talking about
right and wrong,"
Archbishop
Chaput told his audience. "In
reality, our moral beliefs
always shape social policy. Real
pluralism actually demands that
people with different beliefs
should pursue their beliefs
energetically in the public
square. This is the only way a
public debate can be honest and
fruitful."
I would add
whether we are Catholics,
Protestants, a member of another
faith, or profess no faith at
all, we must never apologize for
standing up for those who cannot
defend themselves.
Let me mention
one other "don't"--"Don't create
or accept false oppositions."
The evil genius (my words) that
we saw throughout the campaign
and which will be used to grease
the skids each and every time
Obama undertakes a pro-abortion
initiative is what Archbishop
Chaput called "Dialectical
thinking"-- "the idea that most
of our options involve
'either/or' choices."
As he
explained, "During the last U.S.
election, we saw the emergence
of so-called pro-life
organizations that argued we
should stop fighting the legal
struggle over abortion. Instead
we should join with 'pro-choice'
supporters to seek 'common
ground'"--aka drop the
"divisive" political battle.
As we have
noted in this space many, many
times, this is a two-sided
distortion. Pro-lifers refuse to
accept either/or--to pit mother
against child. We have always,
will always work from the
both/and perspective at the same
time we toil to end abortion on
demand.
"We need to
help women facing problem
pregnancies with good health
care and economic support,"
Archbishop Chaput said, "and we
need to pass laws that will end
legal abortion. We need to do
both."
And what does
dropping the "divisive"
political battle mean? It means
heads the pro-abortionists win,
tails pro-lifers lose. It boils
down to this: Give
pro-abortionists everything they
want and be grateful if they
take it a piece at a time,
rather than in one fell swoop.
Thanks, but no
thanks.
Part One
--
Ground-Breaking Paper Can't
Dissuade Obama From Pursuing
Anti-Life Agenda |