Assisted Suicide Aired on Television
Part One of Two
Editor's note.
Part Two is an important update of the assisted suicide
decision in Montana. Please send your comments to
daveandrusko@gmail.com.
A trifecta of bad news on the
euthanasia/assisted suicide front culminated with the broadcast
on British television of the assisted suicide of 59-year-old
Craig Ewert. (More about that below.)
Just today lawmakers in Luxembourg "trimmed
the powers of Luxembourg's Grand Duke Henri," the Associated
Press reported, when he said he "wouldn't sign a euthanasia bill
into law." The only details of the proposal were that "The law
makes euthanasia and assisted suicide possible after at least
two doctors have been consulted."
The legislature and Henri were at loggerheads
after the monarch on December 2 said he did not "approve" the
bill and could not sign it. The legislature then proceeded to
amend the constitution so that Henri can "'promulgate' --or
formally announce--the euthanasia and assisted-suicide bill
after it gets its final legislative approval Dec. 18"--rather
than "approve" it.
According to the AP, "As in other
parliamentary monarchies, such royal assent is a formality but
required for laws to take effect." The "standoff" was ended when
Henri agreed to amend the constitution.
Out of Scotland comes news that "children aged
12 or even younger could be given the right to assisted suicide
under a radical new Scottish bill proposed by veteran MSP Margo
MacDonald," according to the Guardian.
Last week MacDonald, 65, was unable to secure
enough support to introduce her assisted suicide measure.
Undeterred she is talking about introducing a Private Member's
Bill next year, according to the Times of London. She needs the
backing of 18 members to gain parliamentary time. Currently, she
has won backing from three other members of the Scottish
Parliament.
Under her "End of Life Choices (Scotland)
Bill," Mrs. MacDonald "suggested that the age limit for people
wanting assistance to die should mirror that for children who
are allowed under family law to 'choose a life' by deciding
which parent to live with when couples split up. In Scotland,
youngsters whose parents are divorcing are generally consulted
by the courts over who they wish to stay with from the age of 12
to 16, after which they are legally deemed to be adults."
So, under MacDonald's reasoning, the right to
choose which parent to live with following a divorce = the right
for children to "choose" assisted suicide.
MacDonald has Parkinson's and told reporters
she wants to "spark a 'searching public debate' on her proposals
through the three-month consultation with organizations
including councils, health boards, charities, churches and
health professionals." In addition, "Mrs. MacDonald, who would
like to be allowed to bring about her own death if her condition
deteriorates, believes that it is 'inhumane and ultimately
futile' for the law to deny people the right to choose to end
their life."
But the worst news is what bioethicist Wesley
Smith described as "Tabloid Voyeurism Comes to Assisted
Suicide." Bad enough that Craig Ewert committed suicide by
taking a lethal dose of drugs. Worse yet his death was shown on
television.
Here's how the New York Times describes what
transpired.
"On Wednesday night, Britons could watch Mr.
Ewert's death on television, in a film showing how he traveled
to a clinic in Zurich in 2006 and took a fatal dose of
barbiturates. Broadcast on Sky Television, the film, 'Right to
Die?' is said to be the first broadcast on British television of
the moment of death in a voluntary euthanasia case."
Ewert suffered from what was described as
degenerative motor neuron disease. In the last decade or so
about 100 Britons have committed suicide at Dignitas, the Swiss
clinic.
Peter Saunders, who directs Care Not Killing,
an anti-euthanasia group, denounced the broadcast as "a cynical
attempt to boost television ratings" and persuade Parliament to
legalize assisted suicide," according to the Associated Press.
"There is a growing appetite from the British public for
increasingly bizarre reality shows," Saunders said. "We'd see it
as a new milestone. It glorifies assisted dying when there is a
very active campaign by the pro-suicide lobby to get the issue
back into Parliament."
The film was originally named "The Suicide
Tourist," but renamed "Right to Die?" for its British broadcast
on Sky TV's Real Lives digital channel, "which draws far fewer
viewers than the network's myriad news, sports or movie shows,"
the AP reported. "Still, it generated enormous publicity, with
clips shown throughout the day on Sky News and rival channels."
It is illegal in Britain to "aid, abet,
counsel or procure" suicide. And Prime Minister Gordon Brown
said yesterday he opposed legislation to allow assisted suicide.
"I believe it's necessary to ensure that there's never a case in
the country where a sick or elderly person feels under pressure
to agree to an assisted death, or somehow feels it's the
expected thing to do," he said.
But advocates are ratcheting up the pressure,
using a series of high profile cases to test whom will
prosecuted and under what circumstances. For example, "Mr.
Ewert's wife, Mary, was not prosecuted, despite the fact that
she broke the law by, among other things, helping him travel to
the clinic," the Times reported.
John Smeaton, director of the British pro-life
organization SPUC, warned on his blog today of another threat.
"It has been reported that the government
plans to use its Coroners and Justice bill to clarify the law on
assisted suicide. SPUC is calling on the government to give an
assurance that its plans are limited to its stated aims of
preventing the online promotion of suicide and suicide methods.
We are concerned that radical, so-called right-to-die MPs or
peers--urged on by media coverage for assertions that some
elderly people have a so-called duty to die--might seek to use
the bill to weaken the legal protection of the right to life. We
are therefore also calling upon the government and
parliamentarians to block any attempts to use the Coroners and
Justice bill to weaken in any way the Suicide Act 1961 and the
existing legal prohibition on assisted suicide."
Part Two
updates a story we wrote earlier this week which discusses a
terrible decision legalizing assisted suicide in Montana.
Please send your comments to
daveandrusko@gmail.com.
|