|
"To what end this urgency for a
national debate on death?"
By Dave Andrusko
I
read Canadian author Barbara Kay faithfully in the National Post
because she understands that the culture of death is approaching
a gallop up North and because, as a result of her clarion call,
she is relentlessly battered by the usual pro-death suspects.
Today her opinion piece is
titled, "Quebec's collective depression." It is her reflection
on what she calls "something of a cultural fetish in
Quebec"--euthanasia. (See
here.)
"Films, plays and TV series
portray the suffering who seek out euthanasia or assisted
suicide as our new spiritual nobility, "she writes. "Jean-Pierre
Charbonneau [a former Quebec politician] proudly remarked last
week, in response to the observation that Quebec is the only
province engaged in official encouragement of euthanasia: 'It's
proof that Quebec is distinct!'"
To which Kay observes, "Some
distinction. And no more boast-worthy than Quebec's higher
suicide rate relative to the rest of Canada."
The title of her piece is lifted
from a column that ran last Saturday by journalist Denise
Bombardier. Bombardier asked, "To what end this urgency for a
national debate on death, when we can intuitively sense the
moral collapse of our citizenry, a collapse one might be tempted
to call a collective depression?"
As an outsider I can't speak to
that. I can certainly sympathize with Kay's lamentation that
palliative care is in its infancy in Canada. And if assisted
suicide is legalized, support for what palliative care there is
will surely dry up.
Kay makes a keen observation. One
of the principal driving forces behind a series of hearings on
euthanasia and assisted suicide is a poll of physicians in
Quebec "in which the majority of respondents expressed support
for euthanasia." Lost in translation is that only 20% of the
physicians asked to comment responded--hardly a "clamor."
But Kay understands the power of
emotional appeals and the limitation of what she calls "dry
appeals to reason." However it is also true that there is a deep
well of experience, and that includes what has happened in
Europe, especially the Netherlands where patients are killed
without their consent, including children.
This is not some imaginary,
hypothetical slippery slope. If it is not to happen here--or in
Canada--we must stand like sentinels against the advance of the
Culture of Death.
Please send your comments on
Today's News & Views and National Right to Life News Today
todaveandrusko@gmail.com. If you like, join those who are
following me on Twitter at
http://twitter.com/daveha |